Skip to content
Compliance

Surgical Hand Antisepsis: Scrub Brushes, Waterless Rubs, and What the Guidelines Say

Most surgery centers still buy scrub brushes the way they did in 2005: a case of impregnated brush sponges at the sink, a bottle of alcohol rub beside it, and no written rule on which one the team uses. The guidelines moved. CDC says brushes damage skin. WHO grades "brushes are not recommended" as IB. AORN accepts a surgical hand rub or a traditional scrub. FDA has spent a decade clearing actives out of the health care antiseptic monograph.

Brush scrub versus waterless rub

Two methods meet the guidelines. They use different products in different amounts.

Factor Traditional scrub Waterless surgical hand rub
Product Brush or sponge impregnated with 4% CHG, PVP-I or PCMX, or a dry brush with liquid antimicrobial soap Alcohol-based rub with persistent activity, such as Solventum Avagard (1% chlorhexidine gluconate, 61% ethyl alcohol)
Water Scrub sink required None. The Avagard label says water should not be used
Time 2 to 6 minutes per CDC, 2 to 5 per WHO, set by the manufacturer Per label. Avagard: three 2 mL pumps, rub until dry
Nail cleaning Nail cleaner on the brush, under running water Nail stick at the first use of each day, per the Avagard label
Consumable per scrub One brush About 6 mL
Skin CDC: brushes can damage skin and increase bacterial shedding Avagard label: little change in moisture, scaliness or erythema after repeated use

The purchasing question is which method the OR committee has written into policy; the consumables do not overlap.

What CDC, WHO and AORN say

CDC, 2002 Guideline for Hand Hygiene in Health-Care Settings. Remove rings, watches and bracelets. Clean under the nails with a nail cleaner under running water. Use an antimicrobial soap or an alcohol-based rub with persistent activity before donning sterile gloves. Scrub for the time the manufacturer sets, usually 2 to 6 minutes; 10-minute scrubs are not necessary. With an alcohol-based product, prewash with plain soap, dry completely, apply, and let hands and forearms dry before gloving. On brushes, CDC is blunt: scrubbing with a brush "can damage the skin of personnel and result in increased shedding of bacteria from the hands," and neither a brush nor a sponge is necessary to reach acceptable counts, especially with alcohol-based products.

WHO, 2009 Guidelines on Hand Hygiene in Health Care. WHO grades it: "Brushes are not recommended for surgical hand preparation (IB)." The same section sets scrub time at 2 to 5 minutes, requires alcohol rub on dry hands only, says to keep hands and forearms wet with product throughout, and rules out running a scrub and a rub back to back. The one opening for a brush is visibly dirty hands before entering the OR.

AORN, Guideline for Hand Hygiene. AORN's 2022 update says surgical hand antisepsis can be completed with a surgical hand rub or a surgical hand scrub, allows alcohol-based dispensers inside the OR under fire safety rules, and tells teams to request skin irritation data, including transepidermal water loss, before selecting a product.

The FDA rules that changed the shelf

December 2017, health care antiseptics. FDA ruled that 24 active ingredients, triclosan among them, are not generally recognized as safe and effective in over-the-counter health care antiseptics: personnel hand washes and rubs, surgical hand scrubs and rubs, and patient preoperative skin preparations. Products with those actives became new drugs that need an approved application, effective December 20, 2018. Six actives were deferred and stayed on the market: ethyl alcohol, isopropyl alcohol, povidone-iodine, benzalkonium chloride, benzethonium chloride and chloroxylenol (PCMX).

April 2019, consumer antiseptic rubs. FDA found 28 actives ineligible for the consumer hand sanitizer monograph, triclosan again included, and deferred ethyl alcohol, isopropyl alcohol and benzalkonium chloride. Effective April 13, 2020. This rule governs the sanitizer at your front desk, not the surgical rub in your OR.

For the buyer: a triclosan scrub left in a closet is a product FDA no longer allows into interstate commerce without an approved application. PVP-I and PCMX brushes are legal under the deferral. Avagard is sold under an approved new drug application, NDA 21-074, so the monograph deferrals do not touch it.

Product forms Keystone stocks

Keystone stocks both methods in Edina, Minnesota. In-stock items ship in 1 to 3 business days.

  • BD E-Z Scrub 160 Surgical Scrub Brush/Sponge with Nail Cleaner, No Detergent (BD 371603). A single-packaged brush and sponge with a nail pick and no detergent in the sponge, for use with the CHG or PVP-I liquid soap at your sink. 30 per carton, 10 cartons per case. Impregnated CHG, PCMX and povidone-iodine brushes, nail sticks and liquid scrub soap come through Keystone's 490-plus distributor network.
  • Solventum Avagard Surgical and Healthcare Personnel Hand Antiseptic with Moisturizers, 500 mL (3M / Solventum 9200). 1% chlorhexidine gluconate and 61% ethyl alcohol, brushless and waterless, 8 bottles per case, each supplied with its wall-bracket dispenser assembly. Also stocked by the each as 9216.
  • Avagard D Instant Hand Antiseptic with Moisturizers, 3 oz (9221, 48 per case) and 500 mL pump (9222, 12 per case). 61% ethyl alcohol, no CHG. This is the routine hand antiseptic for use between patients, not the surgical rub. Do not substitute it at the scrub sink.

Stocking math for a surgery center

Size the order from case volume, not headcount.

  1. Count scrub events per day. Cases per day times scrubbed team members per case, typically two to four: surgeon, assistant, scrub tech.
  2. Traditional scrub: one brush per event. 12 cases a day with 3 scrubbed staff is 36 brushes a day, about 756 a month on 21 working days, or roughly 2.5 cases of BD 371603 at 300 per case. Add the liquid CHG or PVP-I.
  3. Waterless rub: 6 mL per event. Three 2 mL pumps per the Avagard label. A 500 mL bottle covers about 83 surgical applications, so the same 36 events a day use about 9 bottles a month. Start with 2 cases of 9200, set a standing order of one case a month, and check the shelf at 90 days.
  4. Nail sticks. The label calls for a nail stick at the first use each day, so budget one per scrubbed staff member per day, not per case.
  5. Plain soap and towels. CDC says to prewash with non-antimicrobial soap and dry completely before an alcohol-based product.

Dispensers and brackets

The 9200 bottle ships with its wall-bracket dispenser assembly and a 2 mL pump, and the 6 mL surgical dose is written as three strokes of that pump. Keep it in its own bracket so the label dose still applies. Placement is a fire question: AORN allows alcohol dispensers inside the OR under fire safety rules, and the Avagard label carries a flammable warning, so clear locations with your life safety officer. Liquid CHG or PVP-I at the scrub sink belongs in a hands-free dispenser.

Write the method into the PO

Pick one primary method, write it into OR policy, and put the consumables on a standing order sized from the math above. Then send Keystone the list. Browse infection control supplies for scrub brushes and surgical hand rubs, request a fast quote with your case volume, or contact the sales department to set par levels. Quotes go out the same business day, Net 30 is available for approved accounts, and if a SKU is backordered Keystone offers a verified equivalent with the lead time shown.

Sources

  • https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/PDF/rr/rr5116.pdf
  • https://apic.org/Resource_/TinyMceFileManager/Academy/ASC_101_resources/Guidelines-APIC-CDC-WHO/WHO_Hand_Hygiene_Guideline_2009.pdf
  • https://www.aorn.org/article/2022-10-10-New-Hand-Hygiene-Practices
  • https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2017-12-20/pdf/2017-27317.pdf
  • https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2019-04-12/pdf/2019-06791.pdf
  • https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatfda_docs/label/2017/021074Orig1s012lbl.pdf
Previous Post Next Post